Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Mystery Novel (Anything Goes)

I love the language in this book. The author uses such a wide range of vocabulary within the descriptions, but it doesn't seem like she's forcing it. Rather, it brings a fluidity to the language, which I find fits the tone perfectly. The tone is brought about by the setting of 1920's to 1930's (during the Great Depression) in the U.S. where during that time, glamor was of the utmost and beauty was useful. It gives a tone of a beautifully fluid surface, with some slight tension underneath, which is like the Brewsters. They're suffering due to the Depression, but still live behind a glamorous mask.

Unfortunately, the supposed surprises don't turn out to be much of a surprise for me, as when they had found the body. I had already guessed they would have found it due to the overly obvious foreshadowing. It took out some of the suspense that would have made the twists and turns much more enjoyable.
However, perhaps that is the style of mystery novel writing during the 90's. (I just looked at the copyright date which was 1999). Perhaps obvious foreshadowing was the popular way to write and was what people enjoyed during that time.

Overall, I liked the book. I thought it had a great plot that was intricate, but simple enough. I like books where there isn't just one problem and one way to solve it, and this book was not one of those. My only problem was the obviousness in the writing. But I still enjoyed reading it.

Sunday, January 13, 2008

Odyseey (16-24)

I like how supposedly glorious it is when Odysseus comes back without the disguise, as himself. I found it slightly funny as well.

I never realized how much power the suitors have. Odysseus is acting as though they are an army of his enemy, not just men beneath him. I thought he could kick them out whenever he wanted, or whenever he returned, because isn't that what Penelope and his people were waiting for? Isn't that why Penelope never married? It doesn't make sense for it to be so hard to return where people want you, for Odysseus's situation, at least.

I like Amphinomus. Though the suitors are looked on as terrible and manipulative, I didn't absolutely hate him, and favor him among the suiters. He just seems like a cool suitor.

Odysseus's plan is clever (disguising himself) but he's not so great at getting passed the suitors, because he keeps getting beat up on the way.

See? Even Odysseus likes Amphinomus, shown when Odysseus warns him to leave because Penelope's husband will be back.

I can't believe Penelope doesn't recognize her husband! You'd think she would, because they were married. It reminds me of this movie where this mother was like, I can recognize any child or grandchild of mine. Then, her daughter-in-law cheats on her husband, but tells the mother that the baby is her son's baby (her real grandchild), and the mother says, Yes, this is my grandchild, he looks just like his father.
But she was wrong.
Anyway, thinking about Penelope, and what a lump she is, it makes me so frustrated that she doesn't know and that Odysseus doesn't tell her because I know, as the reader. And I thought, it might be really cool if the author didn't even share with the reader that Odysseus was the beggar.

Yes I know that Athena loves disguises and is good at them herself, but why is she encouraging this disguise for so long? Odysseus should just tell Penelope and make the suitors leave.

Why does Penelope still want to remarry a suitor even when she has just heard that her husband will be back in a month? Hasn't she been waiting long enough for him? And now she's ready to give up?

With the eagles and talons and doves and bloody walls, I keep thinking of the 10 plagues, and how the suitors were warned, but they refuse to listen.

Why did Odysseus still feel the need to shoot someone with an arrow? And then commence his slaughter of the suitors? WHEN Penelope said she would marry the man that could string the bow and shoot through the axes? Wouldn't she just have married him and all the suitors went home? Because I thought it was a great twist to the story, and Odysseus could have spared himself the murders.

First he orders Eurycleia to be quite ("Keep your joy in your heart, woman") though she had been the one to raise him, and that is no way to speak to her, then he says "It is not decent to boast over slain men." First of all, he was the one that killed them, which was unnecessary, second, he boasts about the disturbing deeds he's done. For example, blinding a cyclopes, which was also unnecessary.

Isn't that kind of unreasonable- killing the "disgraceful" women of the house? It's Penelope's fault for giving them free run of the house and for letting the suitors stay, and isn't the women's fault for mingling with them.

Ok, Odysseus and Telemachus are sadistic and heartless and inhumane and psychotic. They seem almost worse than the suitors, maybe they are worse, shown after what they did to the servant women and Melanthius. Then Odysseus has the house fumigated, as if it were just some common thing, and that what had just happened was insignificant.

Does Odysseus find it funny, when he tricks people with his disguises? Even his own father, who has been grieving his son's absence for all these years?

Athena could have totally put a stop to the violence that Odysseus caused when he killed all of the suitors, and her ability to do so is shown when she stops a fight between the parents and Odysseus.

Wednesday, January 9, 2008

Odyssey (15)

Pre.S. Just found out what that movie was, the cartoon movie with the ship and the sirens and the end of the earth. Actually, it isn't a Disney movie, and it's Sinbad. We should watch that.

How is "'ee" a pun on Telemachus's name?

The way I'm thinking of Telemachus is as one of those princes in the stories, but he's not that smart, and actually quite stupid, and he needs to be told what to do, as Athena needed to tell him what to do in a dream.

Now with all of these people related to the sacking of Troy and the Trojan Horse, I keep picturing certain characters (Menelous, Helen) as those from the movie Troy. We NEED to watch that movie!

There aren't many straightforward explanations of as to how people got where they are. Or perhaps it will be explained later, like how the way Odysseus blinded Poisdeon's son was explained at the end of his tale. Because it wasn't explained exactly how Telemachus was with Peisistratos.

When Odysseus tells Eumaeus that he'll leave in the morning in hopes that Eumaeus will ask him to stay longer (because Eumaeus is a nice man), I thought, Odysseus is so manipulative! He tricked Eumaeus by being a brown noser. Just adds to my feeling for Odysseus that he is self-centered and still in his own world.

Tuesday, January 8, 2008

Odyssey (13-14)

I find it funny how the people refuse to help the sinking ship because it was part of a prophecy. Then I thought about how they acted that way because the gods had so much power over them (because the gods actually had real powers) and how there are so many people who would follow what their religion or leader of religion tells them to do because their religion has such a strong hold on them, that it can make them do anything it wants, even if the act is dangerous or immoral, etc.

I'm confused as to why Athena still feels the need to disguise herself, and then act that way towards Odysseus. Why can't she just come out as Athena and say what she has to say? Well I guess that would make her too humanly then...to be simple minded with simple thoughts.

Eumaeus seems like a really kind person. He reminds me of one of those old people that live in almost the middle of nowhere, or in some weird place, and when a new person in the city/town is travelling and everyone is "too busy" or just too full of themselves to help the new person, that old person will always do so, and be extremely hospitable. It's in movies and stuff.

I'm surprised that the people of Ithaca (including Penelope and Telemachus) still believe that Odysseus is alive, even after 20 years. They take to it such an extreme, that I think they're still assuming Odysseus as king of Ithaca (that's what the was, right?) Perhaps if they weren't such an important family, then it wouldn't matter as much, but since they are, don't they need to crown a new king? Unless Penelope is the ruler, but I'm not sure if women were allowed to rule during that time. You'd think because they're so important and they're leaving such an important position empty, they would do something about it. Perhaps go find Odysseus if they really wanted.

I don't understand the point of Odysseus dressing up as a poor homeless person. Just so we could hear what Eumaeus had to say about it?

Monday, January 7, 2008

Odyssey (12)

I'm kinda surprised at how super nice Circe is, because she's got to be at least a little angry that Odysseus is leaving, yet she's giving him hints and directions that Odysseus might not have survived without them.

But I really like her tiny outburst against the men on page 138.

I remember the Sirens! They were in a movie, probably a couple movies I've seen actually, but the only one I can really think of is a Disney movie where they are sailing to the end of the earth (which is supposedly flat I think). I forget the name of the movie, but I think there was something where they were on a ship and there were sounds and the men wanted to jump off the ship into the ocean. Omg, why can I not remember that movie?! I think it was a pretty good one too. I know it's somewhere in some cartoon movie, pobably Disney. We should totally watch it.
It also reminds me of the 4th Harry Potter movie, with the golden egg, how when Harry opens it underwater, it's like a really pretty voice, because it's the voice of mermaids or soemthing.

Scylla reminds me of the Cracken (sp?) from Pirates of the Carribbean.

What happened on the Sun Island is just like Adam and Eve and the Garden of Eden. They weren't supposed to eat the cow/apple, but they did it anyway, and everyone felt the wrath of Zeus/God.
Yet, Odysseus does not die. But then again, he did not want to kill the cattle. But still, I don't know if he deserved to live while all of his men died. Well why did all of his men have to die? It seems like it was just for the glory of Odysseus.

That's funny. How it ends up back at where he started.

Sunday, January 6, 2008

Odyssey (11)

I just looked up the definition of "odyssey" and it said something like a series of adventures, which I'm assuming is what the book the Odyssey will turn out to be, as it already has. And at first, I was kinda mad that all of the adventures were being told by someone, it is not the actual book (how ironic his name is Odysseus), but it after I read the definition I thought of the movie Big Fish, which is a series of adventures of a man's father, but which were all being told as in the past. So I began to picture the book in that way, which totally changed it for me. Just a something for you to ponder... (Big Fish is a really good movie, btw)

Elpenor is a fool...why did he sleep on Circe's roof?

Troy is a good movie (Agamemnon). We should definitely watch Troy in class.

It must be a tough way to find out that your mother died, and then that YOU caused her death. Bummer for Odysseus, and I just found that it added to the certain self-centeredness of Odysseus.

I'm confused about Otos and Ephialtes. They explained how big they were (but in cubits, so that wasn't so great for me) and then how they wanted to start a civil war. Why? Why did they need to start a civil war against half their family (immortals)?

Ajax- the second death that Odysseus directly caused. Just adding to the self-centeredness.

I like Heracles. He seems wise. Added to the character created by the Disney movie, which is what I'm picturing.

Why do certain people have to still doing things or suffer after they are dead? It almost seems pointless.

Thursday, January 3, 2008

Odyssey (10)

Why did Aiolis feel it was necessary/normal to marry his children together? Does he realize he is creating a family of pure incest?

I'm reading what Odysseus is saying as if the author had written it, and I'm expecting it to be well written and articulate with great descriptions, but I realize that it's just Odysseus, and when a person is telling a story, usually it's not the same as if an author had written the story himself.

Why was Laistrygonian Antiphates's daughter not a giant like him and his wife? And why did Odysseus and his men instantly hate his wife? Just because she was super tall?

I think Odysseus slightly deserved to have boulders thrown at him, because of the way he acted, prejudiced against them and completely unfriendly. He could have possibly saved himself the deaths that were of the dinner of the Laistrygonians if they hadn't acted that way.

How did Odysseus know it was Hermes disguised as the young boy? I thought he was disguised for a reason.

Why Odysseus renouned as "special" or something, as said by Circe? Because of what he did with the giants and cyclopes?
If she was going to act like that, then why didn't Odysseus just tell her who he was in the first place to save him the trouble?

Tuesday, January 1, 2008

Odyssey (1, 5-9)

On page 11, I like the line "For they perished by their own madness..."

I'm really confused about who the people (plus the author has not yet announced the name of the man he is speaking of) and then there is more about other men and the gods and why they are angry, and since I have no background information from the book, nor of greek mythology, I am confused.

How is Poisedon affecting Odysseus? I thought Calypso was holding him captive. And why does Athena want to save Odysseus? And why does she need permission from Zeus?

On page 15, the line "I am the son of a clever father" is probably something that was commonly said during that time, but it almost seems like Athena is mocking Telemachus, or something. It was just the way she decided to use "clever."

When Athena mentions that it's terrible that Telemachus lived his childhood without his father Odysseus, it reminded me of how Marie Antoinette and her husband were beheaded, as I had just seen the movie, Marie Antoinette. And I thought about how their children had to grow up because people thought killing their parents would be the best solution. Did the people think about how Marie Antoinette and her husband were more than rulers, they were parents, daughters/sons, siblings, friends, etc? I found it similar to how Calypso kept Odysseus prisoner. Did she think about how he was a father and a husband? And how many lives she would affect just because of her greediness?

You can buy people in Greece? (Assuming they're in Greece) Wait, yes, you can.

When Calypso retorts with the fact that the male gods have mortal affairs uninterrupted, but when female gods had mortal affairs, they are interrupted, I thought perhaps Homer was possibly making a statement about sexism. Possibly that women have less oppurtunities. Or that women should have less oppurtunities.

I'm confused about the setting. As to where Odysseus's son and wife are, and where the Phaeacians are.

Why didn't Odysseus tell Alcinous of where he was going in the first place?

Did Odysseus realize that the second landing was the place of Cyclopes? Especially since he and the cyclopes had some issues, due to a previous encounter?

I just thought how he yelled "Nobody's killing me" ws so blatant and odd.

Sunday, December 16, 2007

Lord of the Flies (Ch 10-12)

On page 155, what does the author mean by "impaired vision," referring to Piggy and Ralph?
Then, on page 156, I like the line, "The green light and the glossy patterns of sunshine played over their befouled bodies." I like the contrast between the beauty and innocence of the sunshine and the "befouled bodies" because of what they did the previous night.

Thinking about the previous events, and how the boys acted, would it be the same if they were left on the islands as adults? Would they still create two groups and end up killing one of their own, even if they were matured and should know how to act?

Jack seems crazy now, in a mentally unstable psychotic way. Now you can't just blame it on the power, that it just went to his head, because now he's doing things that make him seem completely insane- like beating Wilfred for no reason and convincing the boys that Simon was the beast- especially when you compare him to Ralph. Ralph doesn't seem completely normal either (with the clutching of the conch and laughing hysterically), however he's not acting as crazy as Jack. I think the best way to describe Jack would be to call him a savage tyrant because of the insane way he's acting and the way he is abusing his power.

I'm surprised that Ralph was able to keep his head around the littluns after Jack's attack, when he told them to simply go to sleep. He seems to be maturing, rather than going insane, as Jack has done.

I thought it was funny when Piggy said "I thought they wanted the conch" referring to Jack's tribe because he still thinks the conch is very important.

What is the "moving streak of phosphorence" on page 168?

Why is it cold on the island? Because I assumed that they were on a tropical island, since they had a jungle, and I didn't know that it got cold on tropical islands with jungles.

Why were the fruit trees devasted on page 172?

I thought this was an interesting line on page 180, "Below him, Ralph was a shock of hair and Piggy a bag of fat."

I like how the author compred Pggy to a pig when he died (omg that sounds so mean).

I think the conch symbolized civility and order, so when it broke when the rock hit Piggy, it signified the complete end of any civility.

Where are the littuns of Ralph's group/tribe?

At first I was mad at the twins for acting so rude to Ralph, telling him to "push off" and leave and it made it seem like they just didn't want to leave because they really had joined Jack's group, but then I realized when they gave the meat to Ralph that they joined because they were afraid of Jack coming after them, and what he could do to them because he held so much power of a tribe of boys.

What is the "slow spilt milk" on page 190?

I like on page 196, "Most, he was beginning to dread the curtain that might waver in his brain, blacking out the sense of danger, making a simpleton of him."

On page 199, when the author uses the term "A savage peered..." I began to picture Jack and his tribe as the natives from King Kong because of the paint on their faces and the way the act with their battles cries and such.

I thought that the naval officer would have had more of a grand entrance or introduction. Or maybe the author did that purposely because he wanted to symoblize the fact that the boys had forgotten their main goal, which was being rescued.

I'm not sure that I understand exactly why the officer is there. Well I do, because he said he was there for the fire, but how did he know it wasn't a fire of the enemy, as there is a war going on, and it seems that he came alone, so I don't exactly trust him.

On page 202, the author writes, "And in the middle of them, with filthy body, matted hair, and inwiped nose, Ralph wept for the end of innocence, the darkness of man's heart, and the fall through the air of the true, wise friend called Piggy." I like the line, because I think it is well written, however, with the way Ralph is feeling as a child and in his situation, I don't think it really fit because it was just too smooth and "stable minded," which I doubt is what Ralph was really feeling, and I doubt that's how most people think when they cry like that.

Friday, December 14, 2007

Lord of the Flies (Ch 8-9)

On page 125, the fact that Jack "inexpertly" blows the shell and keeps on doing so until he feels he has everyone's attention made me think differently of Jack. It seems that he really wants the power (took the conch and blew it- only Ralph does it), but since he doesn't know how to use it as well, it made him seem like he would go possibly crazy with power.

With the boys splitting (Jack leaving Ralphs' "lot"), it made it seem like they forgot their priority on the island, which was getting rescued. Now it has become about who has more people in their group, or the better group, or what they can do.
And it's especially worse when the boys sneak away in the night.

Do you think the boys chose a sow, rather than a piglet, because it was bigger? Or because they couldn't bring themselves to kill a baby pig? (because with the sow gone, the piglets may not be able to survive) Do you think it adds that they haven't been living with parents for a while, so killing a sow, isn't that bad?

I think the killing of the sow scene was disgusting, and the boys seem to comfortable with what they did. But I guess that's how they have to be to survive, but the way they killed the pig seemed odd, in a disturbing way.
But then comparing them to hunters, such as Native Americans, who must also kill animals themselves to survive, but the way the Native Americans do it, they still respect the animal. With the boys coming from boarding schools and rich families, I doubt they respect the animal.

I'm confused about the "lord of the flies." I think it is the speared pig head, but I don't understand why it talks, and what it is talking about, and if Simon is only dreaming this.
And I don't understand the line on page 144, "Simon was inside the mouth."

However, I like the line on page 143, "Fancy thinking the beast was something you could hunt and kill."

Ralph is such a hypocrite- first the joining of the hunt, and admitting the adrenaline frenzy he had, and then joining the crazy dancing of Jack's group.

Now the mob mentality, really got to the boys, and they didn't realize to stop what they were doing. Robert was lucky when they stopped, because they hadn't gone that "crazy" yet, but unfortunately for Simon, the boys were going crazy with the beast, the pig, the weather, and the dancing, and they killed him.

Wednesday, December 12, 2007

Lord of the Flies (Ch 6-7)

On page 95, the first line, "There was no light left save that of the stars," my first thought was eery and dark, though, that line may not usually be interpreted that way. However, due to the circumstances and situation of the boys, I thought it was much darker, especially how the author used, "no light left."

I don't understand why they would leave Sam and Eric in charge of the fire. Even Jack couldn't "keep up" with the fire, and do they really think the twins could? The twins that make fun of/annoy the little ones and don't have the best of focus.

On page 100 when the twins are describing the "beast," they add a lot of new feautures to it, including teeth and claws and such, and relating it to the Fear Essay, it may seem that fear distorts things, as the essay claims, and what the twins did, but I think it was because that's what children do. They distort things for attention, though they know exactly what it looks like, but they want people to feel the same fear they do.

I like the phrase, "A knot of boys." It really seems like a knot, thinking about the boys as a mess that you can't undo.

I don't understand the line on page 108, "Mutinously, the boys fell silent or muttering." If the boys fell silent, doesn't that mean they gave in to Ralph, but since the author used the word mutinously, isn't that the opposite?

When Ralph thinks of how the boys have become undiscplined, I thought, why is it that Ralph has so little control over them, compared to the control held over them by adults?
I thought that possibly because Ralph is in the same position as them, and he can't fix the problem (of getting off the island) either, and that signifies child, because adults usually know how to "fix" things.

The incident wth Robert made me think of the scene in To Kill A Mockingbird where the mob of white men come to the jail for Tom Robinson, but when Scout talks to one of the men, he realizes what he is doing. Previous to his talk with Scout, he was in a mob mentality, where they weren't exactly aware of what they were doing, but they were going with the crowd. I thought it was similar to what happend with the boys and Robert, because the boys got so into their mob mentality and Robert acting as the pig, they forget their limits and that it was only a game.

Sunday, December 9, 2007

Lord of the Flies (Ch 3-5)

On page 50, Ralph and Jack talk about how the "littluns" don't do any work, but rather swim or play on the beach. My first thought was that, Ralph and Jack should just make them do work, because if they want to survive, everyone must do their part, but then I realized these children were probably all rich kids who went to boarding schools, and they've probably never done anything for themselves.

I like the line on page 54, "The bottom part of their trickle, as though conscious of their gaze, thickened to a creamy blur which crept up the feeble column." It brings a feeling of a person to the jungle and its objects.

The nightmares that the small children are having make me think that the book is possibly sci-fi rather than just realistic fiction.

I wonder why the author chose to have Simon find the flower butterfly place (page 56). Possibly, there could be some kind of trick to it or Simon finds something odd there.

The author seems to be personifying the elements and the jungle, (page 58) "the sun gazed down like an angry eye." It makes the jungle even more creepy and disturbing.

On page 62 what does "a darker shadow crept beneath the swarthiness of his skin" mean?

The missing fire, that the hunters and jack should have tended to. Just another thing to fuel the enmity brewing between Jack and Ralph. (pun intended)

But since it's there's a war going on, couldn't the boat possibly be the boat of an enemy?

I like how Jack twitches when he proudly says he cut the pig's throat on page 69.

Why were they not sharing the pig with the little kids?

There seems to already be some sort of rankings on the island, as seen on page 78.

After watching the show Lost, I don't ever think I could sleep on an island in the boys' situation. I wouldn't know what could be in the forest or what might happen. I wouldn't trust myself or the jungle.

It's sad about Percival because he's in a traumatic situation and the boys' certainly don't know how to help him.

Thursday, December 6, 2007

Lord of the Flies (Ch 2)

The author uses the word "creepers" a lot, and I think he's referring to vines and plants of the jungle, but since he chose that word (unless that was the common uses word for plants) it brings an eery and disturbing feel to the jungle.

I keep thinking of the show Lost and the jungle and characters on that show, especially Jack, because one of the main characters in the book is named Jack.

On page 34, I like the line, "The breezes that on the lagoon had chased their tails like kittens were finding their way across the platform and into the forest."

With the snake thing, I thought of the movie Anaconda.

On page 39, I like the phrase, "Their black caps of maintenence" referring to the choir boys.

I don't understand why Ralph had to stand on his head, on page 39.

I'm confused as to why on page 46, the boys all start yelling "Snakes! Look!" Does it mean they see snakes or something? And what is the drumroll on the other side of the mountain on page 47?

Lord of the Flies (Ch 1)

I don't understand the line on page 7, "All round him the long scar smashed into the jungle was a bath of heat."

I found it odd, on page 8, and almost ironic that the fat boy said, "Perhaps there aren't any grownups around." The use of the word grownup make him seem young and naive, yet he used the word perhaps, which made him seem more mature, and I wasn't sure of his age anymore.

I don't understand the fair boy's explanation regarding the pilot on page 8...

How can both of the boys just drop the subject of the boys that were in the part of the plane that was burning? (page 8-9)

I'm confused as to why Ralph saw it necessary to take off his clothes. (page 10)

On page 14, I like the phrase "wrestling with the brilliance of the lagoon." However, I don't understand the whole metaphor.

So I guess I can assume the boys are from Europe, more specifically Britain, or at least Piggy is because he said "pounds" referring to payment.

For some reason, in the descprition of the choir boys, the fact that they wore a cross stood out to me.

Why on page 24 does Ralph accept Simon to go exploring with them, even though Simon had just fainted and he had heard of Simon's fainting spells?

On page 31, though I thougth Jack was a fool for wasting the opportunity to kill the pig, I understood because where he lived, he probably had every meal served to him and never had to kill an animal himself.

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Great Expectations (55-59)

All of a sudden, Pip feels something more than disgust towards the convict, and the convict had to first attack a man, get arrested, and end up in jail for Pip to finally realize that he wasn't the same man as he was before in the marshes years ago.

I thought the first paragraph of chapter 55 provided some foreshadowing- possibly dark, yet happy in a peaceful way.

It seems that everyone is getting married but Pip. It shows how alone Pip is. I think that he also made a mistake, as he had brushed off Biddy for Estella, who had seemed to be a lost cause.

Is Jaggers married?

I almost thought that Pip was going to pray for himself, after Magwitch dies, instead of praying for Magwitch.

When Joe came for Pip, I saw it as another comparison of Joe and Pip. Though Pip had treated Joe coldly and inferior, Joe still came for Pip and helped him back to health. Also, Joe's life was one Pip could have had. Pip would have been a lowly blacksmith, but he would have been happy and content with life, and not in debt. He also could have possibly married Biddy.

Isn't Biddy Pip's age? Which is about 20 years younger than Joe (Mrs. Joe was 20 years older than Pip), so wouldn't Joe be a little old for Biddy?

Biddy still seems very kind and thoughtful, yet I sense a new maturity in her. I think it's in the way she speaks to Pip, like she's wiser.

Pip still seems to be infatuated with Estella and still possesses his dreams of being her husband, even through all of the years and rejection, Pip is still able to wish they were together.

Great Expectations (53-54)

On page 425, I like the line, "Beyond their dark line there was a ribbon of clear sky, hardly broad enough to hold the large red moon." Knowing that Pip was walking into the marshes due to a threat letter, thus the mood was dark and suspenseful, yet the use of "ribbon" foreshadows a little brightness.

How would Orlick be connected with Magwitch? Because I thought the man in the marshes would have been Compeyson.

Why does Orlick call Pip "wolf"?

On page 443, in the first paragraph, Pip mentions the word "mud" several times. Is that because he does not like mud? Or he feels stuck in the mud (both literally and figuratively)?

On page 443, one man says, "What was that ripple?" and it made me think of that scene in Jurassic Park where the kids and the lawyer are in the car and the water in the cup shakes every few moments because the T-Rex is taking steps.

On page 445, why did the dialogue make Pip and his men uneasy? And Pip even more uneasy? For Pip, I thought it was possibly because it reminded him of when he was common and those who he knew spoke that language (Joe, Orlick)?

Was it really worth it to Magwtich to attack Compeyson, though he would get caught?

Great Expectations (50-52)

The first paragraph of chapter 50 describes how and where Pip was burned by the fire at Miss Havisham's, and I found it slightly odd that he described only the physical aspects of the burns. He said nothing about how he felt- if he regretted saving Miss Havisham or if he thought the burns were completely worth it.

On page 408, while Herbert is thoughtfully wrapping Pip's burns with bandages, Herbert is constantly asking Pip if he is ok with the bandaging or if he is in pain, but Pip pays no attention to him because all he can think about is finding the truth. I found it comical how Herbert was trying to be kind, but Pip just brushed him off, instead telling Herbert to continue with the story.

I thought Jaggers would have known that Provis was Estella's father, as he had defended her mother in a case. Also, he had helped the man and I thought it was because of Molly/Estella. (page 409)

On page 416, Jaggers explains how Molly let Estella go. But I still don't understand why Molly had to let Estella go- yes, Estella is "saved" even if Molly is not, but didn't it lead to the court thinking that Molly had killed Estella?

On page 418, it really shows how snappish and uptight Wemmick is in the office when Mike walks in, and I found it funny, yet disturbing at the same time.

I don't understand the note on page 420.

On page 423, when Pip is asking about Pumblechook and Joe, I felt- from Pip's point of view- superior towards them, possibly towards their absence in the book and possibly the way Pip asked about them.

Does the landlord not recognize Pip? Because he speaks of him. (Page 423)

Saturday, November 24, 2007

Great Expectations (48-49)

On page 390, last paragraph, I really like the sentence "...and we went along Cheapside and slanted off to Little Britain, while the lights were springing up brilliantly in the shop-windows, and the street lamplighters, scarcely finding ground enough to plant their ladders on in the midst's of the afternoon's bustle, were skipping up and down and running in and out, opening more red eyes in the gathering fog than my rush-light tower at the Hummums had opened white eyes in the ghostly wall." I thought it was great scenery and imagery.

Why does Pip change his mind to join Jaggers only when Jaggers mentions that Wemmick will be there? (page 390)

I'm assuming Bentley Drummle is the "Spider"? (page 392)

No way! No way! I will not believe that Molly is Estella's mother (as claimed by Pip on page 393). Ok, yes i will believe it, but that is such a huge surprise! More "coincidental" connections in somehow all related to Pip.

Since Molly was almost convicted for killing her own daughter (who is most likely Estella), and assuming Molly was being convicted because they could not find her daughter, then why could they not find Molly's daughter? (page 396)

On page 400, Pip says, "There have been sore mistakes; and my life has been a blind and thankless one; and I want forgiveness and direction far too much to be bitter with you." It shows that Pip realizes his mistakes, yet is still ungrateful (possibly due to the convict), yet still feels a bit superior, as he says "to be bitter with you." Pip would not have said that unless he felt confident and superior, rather than him being a lowly blacksmith.

On page 403, Pip says "running at me" referring to Miss Havisham, and I don't think I could picture Miss Havisham running, due to her old age and the way she lived. I pictured her instead sitting and then yelling at Pip to help her (though she in on fire, she still keeps her superiority and dignity).

Monday, November 19, 2007

Great Expectations (45-47)

On page 368, I like the use of personification "the clock whispered, the fire-place sighed..." I was also able to relate to Pip, when I would be lying in bed, unable to sleep, the noises of my house would get louder and seem to be alive, including the clock ticking and the doors creaking.

During chapter 45, I felt the intensity and suspense building, as Compeyson was chasing after Magwitch and due to the note from Wemmick telling Pip to not go home. Now there is the problem of Compeyson, who could hurt Pip and his family and friends, just because of Magwitch. It almost seems like the fee for becoming a gentleman and receiving the money, Pip now has to deal with Compeyson.

I like how Pip compares Clara and her father as a "captive fairy" and "trucelent ogre."

I feel that Clara is in the same situation as Compeyson's wife. They are both stuck with terrible uncaring men who look upon their women as inferior and no more than a servant. Yet both women stick to their men and care for them diligently, for fear of lack of money or shelter or just fear, or the women feel it is their duty to stay with this person because in Clara's case, it's her father, and for Compeyson's wife, because it's her husband.

I can relate with Pip, on page 383, when he does not look into the information of if Estella and Drummle had married yet, though he knows it has already probably happens, but if he does not hear confirmation, he can ignore it and pretend as if it never happened. I've done the same, where I don't want to hear something, and I think that if I don't actually hear it, it's not real.

While Pip is describing the events of the play Mr. Wopsle is in, I think he definitely affects what I think of that play, though I have never seen or read it. By subtly adding opinionated adjectives and phrases, I already had a judgement of a play I had never seen. I found it to be comical- but not supposing to be- and a bit ridiculous- though I am sure the play was meant to be real and serious.

Also on page 387, Pip says, "And I observed with great surprise that he devoted it to staring in my direction as if he were lost in amazement," referring to Mr. Wopsle. It showed that Pip was no longer as conceited as before (due to the wake up call from Magwitch) as Pip says he was surprised, however he still has a feel of superiority by using the term "lost in amazement."

I find that Compeyson sitting behind Pip without even trying to scare Pip directly makes the situation even more frightful because the way Compeyson is choosing. Instead of directly attacking Pip, he is reaching him through his family, as Compeyson probably knew Mr. Wopsle had some relation to Pip. It makes Compeyson seem even more clever and smarter, thus a more frightening pursuer.

Great Expectations (42-44)

What is "silver tea-kittle"? As mentioned by the convict "I've been locked up as much as silver tea-kittle" on page 345.

I really like Magwitch's analogy of his name to the names of birds on page 345, because I had never thought of having a name in that sense and the truth in it. It also added to how Magwitch was alone in life and how he only had himself to depend on.

Why would Compeyson's wife stay with him if he was such a terrible husband, as Magwitch claims on page 348, where he says Compeyson abuses her and also has dreams of her attacking him and he insults her?

PAGE 352- one of my favorite pages. First of all, that is absolutely crazy, the way that Magwitch is connected with Miss Havisham. And secondly, it was written simply (compared to the rest of the book) thus, with just one read of the two sentences, I was able to understand completely, which defintely added to the impact. However, I'm not sure if that was Dickens intentions- to make it simple and clear to add to the impact?

On page 354 in the fourth paragraph, I really liked the metaphor comparing the beginning of the day to a beggar because it already sets a mood for the upcoming events.

On page 354, Drummle and Pip pretend not to see each other, which I find to be childish and ridiculous. It reminds me of when you know a person, and you pass them, but both do nothing to acknowledge each other.

I don't understand why Pip feels so disgusted by his benefactor that he can longer even keep in contact with Estella. He should feel grateful to Magwitch, and I think part of this repulsion is due to what Estella may think of him.

On page 359, Pip says "as plainly as if she had told me with the dumb alphabet" referring to Estella pausing her knitting and flinching her fingers. Dickens's word choice of "dumb alphabet" shows that Pip is still blinded by Estella and feels her superior to the rest of the world and himself.

On page 363, when Estella is speaking of how she is to be married to Drummle, my first thought was, no, she should be marrying Pip because Drummle is a fool. But then I thought of how this is all from Pip's point of view and his pessimistic view on Drummle definitely influenced me as the reader, and I thought that possibly Drummle is very different with Estella and the reason for marrying him is because she really does like him.